Ender’s Game
The Story
The Earth has been attacked twice by aliens called Formics, or more popularly, Buggers, and everyone is sure a third invasion is coming. So the military embarks on a crash program to breed the ultimate military genius to lead the fleet in a pre-emptive attack against the Formic home world. These kids are trained from age 6 in an off-world facility called Battle School, and their training consists mostly of games.
Ender Wiggins may be the child they are looking for. Brilliant, compassionate, and tormented, he is better at the games than anyone has ever been. But how can they manipulate a compassionate child into wiping out an entire species, and at the same time give him the skills to do it effectively? The adults who run the school are literally out to save the world: they will stop at nothing to achieve their ends, and one small boy, or even a school full of kids, are nothing but means to that end.
The Book
For many Ender’s Game is one of the great ones, a novel of extraordinary power that is among the very best the science fiction genre has ever produced. But the are critical voices being annoyed by the “chosen child” theme resembling the birth of Jesus itself. A redditor put it this way:
“It’s pure escapist fantasy for picked-upon kids in middle school who are relatively small and weak and think they’re smarter than everyone else. When read as a kid it’s a fantastic triumph of the clever over the brutal and a story of how the entire world learns to appreciate the true worth of a seemingly ordinary little boy.
Then you reread it as an adult and see how myopic it really is. It’s not that well written, the characters are shallow, the science fiction aspects are weak and the ending is obvious a hundred pages out. […] I’m not even going to touch on the fascistic social engineering he suggests is going on in the background. Overall the book comes off as much lamer than you remember.“
The Author
Orson Scott Card, the author of Ender’s Game, is what keeps some people from buying the book. He’s a right-wing Mormon who wrote opinion pieces against same-sex marriage and demanded laws banning homosexual behaviour to stay in effect (while his young, mostly male, characters spend a good part of the book completely naked. Makes one wonder…). He also suggested that there is a conspiracy to supress publications of scientists who don’t believe in global warming.
The Film
A film is in production with 15-year-old Asa Butterfield (pictured bleow) playing Ender. But as Declan pointed out in the milkboys forums: “The release date for Ender’s Game has been pushed back to Nov. 2013. Principal photography is still ongoing and going by his tweets, [Asa] seems to be having a blast with his castmates. Also, he’s apparently got himself a girlfriend recently, a news met with much wailing and gnashing-of-teeth by 12 year-old girls on tumblr –ell oh ell.
At some point in the future you will have to ask yourself how you’re going to deal with Ender’s Game. To watch it in theaters is to directly/indirectly support Asa –which, unfortunately, also means directly/indirectly supporting Orson Scott Card the homophobe.“






about 1 year ago
Did you ever wonder why the enemy were called “buggers”?
about 1 year ago
Was Orson Scott Card really a homophobe. I can remember reading a book called Songmaster by him that had definite gay undertones as well as a gay character.
about 1 year ago
Yes, Card is a very active homophobe, and right wing nut job. Just look him up on the web. So, if you pay to see “Ender’s Game” you are putting money in the pocket of someone who wants to see us removed from society.
about 1 year ago
And now you understand why he is considered by many to be at the very least a closet ephebophile, if not actually a closet homosexual. Several of his books, from Songmaster, to Wyrms, to many of the Ender’s books, reference beautiful, male, often nude boys, and while sometimes mentioned to be “wrong”, the narrative just assumes that boys are automatically going to draw lustful attention.
about 1 year ago
Sounds like a huge closet case to me. I feel sorry for him. Nevertheless, it’s one occasion I’ll feel good about downloading something on Bittorrent instead of paying for it.
about 1 year ago
Well, Asa Butterfield and all his wisdom might have something to say about that. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=htCCGhKYdeA
Good actor and all but this just makes me hate him. Think I’ll just casually pirate everything he appears in from now on.
about 1 year ago
I’d take a second thought about getting angry at a 14-yo boy who’s still “high” after being in a blockbuster movie. I would presume he’s been heavily pressured by the “powers that be” in the studio that hired him to say that or very similar — and as often as he “can get it in” interviews, conversations about (his or other) movies.
about 1 year ago
Hahaha, I’m not sure about that, maybe he said it in jest. He was born only 2 years before Napster, he’s probably aware of how much warnings like that go unheeded.
about 1 year ago
*cough* *cough*
http://simmonsenglish.pbworks.com/w/file/48187120/Ender%27s%20Game%20FULL%20TEXT.pdf
about 1 year ago
Haha, thanks!
about 1 year ago
I have being following Asa’s career for a long time and I look forward to seeing the movie. Asa’s appearance has changed quite a bit over the last 3 years.
As to “how we are going to deal with Ender’s Game” – Asa has is not against gay people, in fact he thinks they are cute.
about 1 year ago
It’s only a movie….
Why support Asa? That’s weird…..
Stereotyping all cute looking teens as hoped for gay icons … HMMmmmm
File share and think ‘Down with Orson Scott Card’ har har har (Pirate laughter!)
about 1 year ago
How is it that a person who writes books I remember so well as soul-wrenching, loving, tortuous, be such a jack-ass as to be a homophobe? Then again, perhaps it is my memory of the book that was so good, not the story itself. That’s the fun of fiction, you can fill in the blanks, the blind spots, with a creation of your own making rather than the author’s.
Perhaps it’s easier to write fiction than live fact, at least for Card.
-randy
about 1 year ago
“At some point in the future you will have to ask yourself how you’re going to deal with Ender’s Game. To watch it in theaters is to directly/indirectly support Asa –which, unfortunately, also means directly/indirectly supporting Orson Scott Card the homophobe.”
From your description of him (I haven’t read anything he’s written), I wouldn’t necessarily call him a homophobe as an “end-all.” It sounds more like he’s a latent homosexual that, because of that religion, he feels he has to present some [asinine] homophobic face to the public just to “save face” with them and his family.
But, from your description of the movie, and also his performance in Hugo, I’ll probably rent the DVD (it’d be worth it for just a couple of bucks). :-)
about 1 year ago
I will not be seeing this film or buying the books. Regardless of their merit, I will never willingly support an avowed bigot.
about 1 year ago
I may be going against the grain here but I didn’t like Ender’s Game that much. Some clever bits but I found the narrative a bit plodding. I borrowed the book as i would not put a penny in Card’s pocket (i’ll wait for the film to come out on torrent). I have also read Songmaster which has definate homo/paederastic overtones which I found hard to square with Card’s rantings elsewhere. All in all a strange individual indeed.
about 1 year ago
It”s about time someone made Ender’s Game into a movie I just hope I will be alive to see it. It doesn’t matter what card is, he has a right to be here just like we do.
about 1 year ago
I try not to worry about homophobes too much, but now Asa Butterfield is a different matter. I love this kid. Not because he is very cute and super intelligent but also because of his depth of talent in the movie business. His resume is incredible for his young years. He also has some of the most beautiful blue eyes on the planet. Go Asa !!!
about 1 year ago
I’ve bought all of Card’s books in the past and will see the movie.
about 1 year ago
I enjoyed a number of his topics that was introduced into the books. I got bored of the repetitive style with the Bean section, and found that he lapsed occasionally in the complexity of the characters reasoning for doing certain actions. I couldn’t buy the start of the Songmaster series, so never ended up buying any of those…
The Homophobic bit, I’m not really surprised; even if you exclude the Mormon upbringing.
about 1 year ago
I’ll probably not see the movie when it first comes out. I’m going to wait and see how the reviews are before I see it. The one thing I’d be looking forward to seeing is the battle scenes in the school, I’m wondering how they will do them.
As for Card I’ve met him at SF conventions more than a few times. I think it’s more his Mormon religion than active homophobia that gives him his outlook. At least in Ender’s Game there’s no sexual overtones, in Songmaster the gay character, as in most stories (even those written by gay authors) ends up dead.
about 1 year ago
Orson Scott Card is no homophobe. You would know that if you actually read his Uncle Orson columns. But, as is the case in many of these posts, the facts just get in the way
about 1 year ago
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orson_Scott_Card#Homosexuality
about 1 year ago
It’s long, but pretty much sums it up. He has written more on the subject from time to time since then. http://www.ornery.org/essays/warwatch/2004-02-15-1.html
about 1 year ago
Well, this is very interesting. Card’s website, hatrack.com, was formerly bristling with literally hysterical anti-gay rantings–for example, in one essay, he specifically stated that he’d feel no loyalty to a constitutional order in which same-sex marriage was recognized. Checking hatrack.com today, as well as orsonscottcard.com, I find very little evidence of these articles–there’s a link to an article posted to the uber-homophobic Family Research Council website, but the article itself has been taken down.
“Songmaster” begins, IIRC, with the brutal rape of a young boy by an instructor to whom he’s apprenticed.
“Enders Game” describes how preteen boys and girls spend most of their time at Battle School in complete nudity. I’d not be surprised to learn that Card is a closet pedophile, rather than a closeted gay guy. I suspect that Battle School uniform will undergo a change for the movie version.
I do consider him a gifted writer, though, although I agree that the conclusion of “Ender’s” was telegraphed well in advance. But, that’s not really the point. Card also wrote “Ender’s Shadow,” about Ender’s friend Bean, who, though more of a military genius than Ender, lacks qualities of leadership–and “suffers” from too much empathy.
But, if I can handle Mel Gibson’s movie, “Apocalypto,” then I’m sure “Ender’s Game” will work for me.
about 1 year ago
““Songmaster” begins, IIRC, with the brutal rape of a young boy by an instructor to whom he’s apprenticed.”
No it does not.
about 1 year ago
I read the short story when it first saw the light of day in a pulp magazine. 1976?
harrison ford’s character,colonel graff, is described as morbidly obese. Think that will carry over?
ender is atacked by his rivals when both he and they are naked in the showers. think that will remain in the movie?
about 1 year ago
“Let the Right One In”
Need I say more…?
about 1 year ago
Love Enders Game, been following very closely, I respect OSC as a writer, he doesn’t put himself in the book, he lets the book tell the story, there is one point in the Shadow series, mayhaps Shadow of the Giant, where a character talks about love, and he is very even handed about it, not going against gays at all. Plus i like asa, and The rest of the cast seems great, Its going to be a blast :)
http://www.endernews.com/ http://endersgameblog.tumblr.com/
about 1 year ago
ah so!
about 1 year ago
That’d be “Ender Wiggin” without the “s” at the end! I really enjoyed this book when I was younger and have eagerly anticipated a movie production for many years. Card may be a homophobe but that won;t stop me going to see the movie.
about 1 year ago
Unfortunately, some of us are old enough to have read Ender’s Game and many of his other books long before he actively showed himself to be a homophobe
having read his books, though… I would seriously have thought he was, at the very least, tolerant of homosexuals and ephebophiles. Maybe something changed for him in the late 90′s, early 2K’s? I don’t really know, but it just seems to me, having followed him, that starting in the late 90′s he has progressively become more and more virulent against gay’s. Also, try reading the book Lost Boys by him (absolutely no connection to the movie!)
Sad, the feeling I got from reading his books, was that he very much felt boys to be special, wonderful creatures capable of far more than anyone else realizes…
about 1 year ago
Hmmm…judging from that, then it seems Card may have just gone further in the closet? After all, the more self-hatred stirs, the further contemptuous one tends to become of their own attractions, especially if it is viewed as deviant by the general public. Plus he’s Mormon, so that may play into it as well.
If he is a homophobe however, I tend to have an objective opinion when reading or viewing someone’s artwork.
Oftentimes, that reveals more about the character of the author, but regardless, I end up appreciating the work itself and don’t read too much into the lifestyle of the person who created it because if I wanted an autobiography, I’d go find one.
about 1 year ago
Card may well be a homophobe, but why should that stop me reading his books, or seeing a film based on them?
If we were to boycott every book whose author was perceived to be homophobic, misogynist, racist, corrupt, unscrupulous, etc etc, we’d leave ourselves with a very sparse selection of books to read.
Boycotting books because the authors are homophobes is not all that far removed, hypothetically, from people boycotting books or music because the authors are/were gay.
When I find someone’s BOOKS are pushing an offensive line, be it racism, sexism or any other form of bigotry, THEN I will stop reading him or her.
about 1 year ago
Well said! :)
about 1 year ago
Asa is way too old for this role. River Phoenix was younger – 13 I think, in Stand By Me. Daniel Radcliffe was 11 in the first Harry Potter. Ender is supposed to be 8 – couldn’t they have found a 10-12 year old for this? I’m thrilled that the movie is going to be made but if that youtube linked by BD is any indication, they are going to have to raise his voice by a couple notes to avoid cognitive dissonance.
about 1 year ago
I completely agree. And Asa isn’t the only kid that’s too old. A few of the young actors are almost 18! I was hoping this reported cast list was a sick rumor or something. Unfortunately that doesn’t seem to be the case. Check this out:
http://geektyrant.com/news/2011/10/21/enders-game-movie-details-orson-scott-cards-response-to-geek.html
This was less than half a year ago, and what Card says about the casting goes completely against what actually happened. Really frustrated about this.
about 1 year ago
Similar to how they had to do Billy Elliot, because Jamie Bell grew older during filming. At one point, they had to shave his legs to keep the continuity.
about 1 year ago
I am on the fence whether to tag above as TMI.
Though, Caspian in the recent Narnia turned out decent, if not faithful to the original work.
about 1 year ago
I think this lad is very talented and yes I would go see the movie or get the DVD just as I did in Hugo.I find nothing that ASA has said that was against gays.Now CARD has made some statements that I disagree with,and they were back in the 90′s. There are straight folks that I don’t agree with as well as gay folks,but if they put out a good book or a good movie,you can bet the farm on it ,that I’ll either read or see it.I have no time in this life to boycott thinks that other folks may or may not like.Now I know that Ender is younger in the book,but this ASA has so much talent and he is so cute with those oh so beautiful eyes. I guess I well just get the DVD.
about 1 year ago
Ok, so Card isn’t such a big fan of homosexuality. I can’t say I love that part about him, but he does have the right to his own opinion.
Bottom line though: Ender’s Game is an absolutely superlative piece of writing and by boycotting the book or movie for its author’s politics, you’re simply doing yourself a disservice. And contrary to one of the critics in the article, I found it far better when I reread it as an adult. I’d just turned 11the first time around, and while I liked it, I think a lot of the bigger ideas went straight over my head. I picked it back up when I was 17, and a couple more times since then. It has since taken its place as one of my all time favorites.
To the people considering holding Card’s homophobia against Asa; you’re kidding me right? So a young teenage boy is not only supposed to have the political awareness to to blacklist someone for homophobia, but also a duty to? At the expense of his buddy career?
It seems that the extension of that argument is that its everyone’s duty to oppose homophobia by reacting every bit as violently against it as the homophobes do against the gay community. Massive practical issues aside, can anyone else see the irony of promoting hatred and intolerance as a solution to intolerant and hateful beliefs of others?
In case my presence on this site didn’t spell it out: I am gay, I’m completely in favor of gay rights, and I’m certainly not a fan of homophobia. I simply think that there is a right way and a wrong way to address it.
about 1 year ago
TIM,you hit the nail right on the head.Your words where just out standing,and I too an gay.I believe that boycotting is just not a one way street,it runs both ways.Thanks again,Tim for your words.
about 1 year ago
The reasons I can’t read anything from this Pig Person.
1. I suspect he’s a latent “Everything I Dis, I Am” person. If he can’t help being an idiot, I’m not capable of forgiving him.
2. He encourages vulnerable gay kids to feel shitty about themselves; therefore he merits the endless fury of an eternal afterlife in Hell. If only, in this case, there was one.
about 1 year ago
I don’t recall him having ever said anything to make vulnerable gay kids feel shitty about themselves. If someone wants to supply a quote to the contrary, go for it, but I sure haven’t heard it.
I think there is a bit confusion about two very important words here: Tolerance and Acceptance. Tolerance is the ability for someone (in this case a gay person) to exist and live without fear of harassment or abuse, be it verbal or physical. Acceptance in this context would be others agreement with or even endorsement of a gay person’s sexuality/lifestyle. Tolerance is a right, no gay person should ever have to fear for their safety or endure harassment or bullying. Acceptance isn’t guarantied, nor should it be forced, a person with strong religious beliefs doesn’t have to accept you for your sexuality. Nor do you have to accept them for their beliefs, or for any other reason that you like. And for what it’s worth; if they don’t accept you for who you are, why are you wasting any of your time on them?
Coming back to Card, I haven’t read ALL of his books, but I have read most of them at least once. None of those that I have encountered have had any sort of anti-gay beliefs or rhetoric in them.
I have also read the essay that many of the participants in this thread cite for his homophobic/gay-hating beliefs “The Hypocrites of Homosexuality”. It’s been a few years, and it’s a fairly old essay, but the main point of the piece is that its both wrong, and hypocritical that many gay activists seek to promote tolerance and acceptance of homosexuality, but refuse to tolerate that other people may not accept it, or may even believe it to be immoral or wrong. You certainly don’t have to agree with those beliefs, I certainly don’t, but in order to expect tolerance for yourself, you should practice tolerance toward others, even if you find them distasteful. I tolerate people with strong religious beliefs, even if they disapprove of my sexuality. I can’t say I usually like them much, and they usually don’t like me, but so long as the tolerate me, I return the favor. To clarify: tolerance of homophobia should NEVER be extended to those who promote violent, hatred, or the harassment toward gays. But so long as it stops with disapproval, it needs to be tolerated.
The point that I’m trying to make here isn’t to endorse of defend Card’s personal beliefs, or homophobia in general. The point is that you cannot hope to spread tolerance toward yourself if you fail to practice it toward others. Furthermore, choosing not to tolerate someone else for their beliefs and lifestyle, while expecting them to tolerate you for yours, is hypocrisy of the highest order, and does nothing but alienate moderates, and harm the cause of spreading tolerance and acceptance for gays.
about 1 year ago
“Card has publicly declared his disapproval of homosexuality and of marriage rights for gay men and women. In 1990, Card called for laws that ban homosexual behavior to “remain on the books… to be used when necessary to send a clear message that those who flagrantly violate society’s regulation of sexual behavior cannot be permitted to remain as acceptable, equal citizens within that society”,”
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orson_Scott_Card#Homosexuality
Telling gays they’re not normal, they don’t deserve to marry and their behaviour should be banned by law sure sounds like something that would make a gay teen feel shitty.
about 1 year ago
Frankly, if your only source is wikipedia you have to take that with a grain of salt. I realize you have an ax to grind, but Orson Scott Card as a man and as a writer should be far down your list.
about 1 year ago
Wow!!!
So you really took down my last comment?
Didn’t like my quote, or what?
If there is a legitimate reason for that, feel free to let me know, and I’ll apologize, but right now, it just looks like you didn’t want to respond.
about 1 year ago
Tim I think he doesn’t understand what you are saying, Everyone has the right to be here, that was the way it was years ago, before man set himself up above God, and judge everyone, to what they think they should be. I just hope the movie does honor to the book of Ender. I don’t care who or what wrote it, it is a d_mn good book.
about 1 year ago
Youtube has trailer of Ender’s Game you can watch. What I have seen they are great. At least they are nude from the waist up in the shower scence. maybe they be true to the book.
about 1 year ago
Awesome book, i hope the film does it justice.
As for Card, he must have homo tendancies cos enders game is boy erotica.
about 1 year ago
who in world cares about card, he had a other good book about a young boy, 3 in the set, can’t remember the name one should care about the book and film not who or what wrote it. If he was or wasn’t whatever, whatever give him the ability to write the book, to change card you will change the book, think about it the only was he could write the book is by being himselfwhatever what is. Just hope the film is just as erotica and full on nudes. yeah.!!!
!
about 3 months ago
I also disagree that an author’s/artist’s works should be judged in light of his world view. Card is an excellent writer, and those of his works that I’ve read do not impress me as homophobic.
Ender’s Game is a great book and a good story. My favorite by him though, is Speaker for the Dead. Really great story and premise, with interesting implications.
I will probably see the movie, but I will also look into whether these claims about Card check out. If they do, I will be dissapointed, but he’s still a great author, and I won’t stop reading his works. He’s entitled to his views, just as we are, though I will continue fight for public support of my own way of life.