Glee & Queer Youth Struggles
As the only openly gay student at the fictional McKinley High, Kurt Hummel faces the same sort of harassment and torment that many teens experience on a daily basis. But last night’s episode of the Fox megahit Glee paved a hopeful road for Kurt, in which he not only bonds with a gay teen from a rival glee club, but also finally finds the courage to stand up to his tormentor. And in typical Glee fashion, the result comes as something as a surprise to both Kurt and the audience.
The episode “Never Been Kissed” begins with Kurt growing increasingly frustrated by the regular bullying he endures and the blind-eyes being turned by his peers and the school’s faculty. Despite Mr. Schuester’s attempt to reach out, Kurt’s feelings of alienation reach a breaking point after his song ideas are roundly rejected by the other boys in glee club. As a result, he agrees to spy on a rival school his team will soon be competing against in sectionals, where he makes an unexpected friend.
Unlike the often oppressively homophobic McKinley High School, the Dalton Academy has a zero-tolerance bullying policy, and it’s there that he meets Blaine. Confident, talented, and popular, Blaine is practically a walking, talking “It Gets Better” video. He also understands Kurt’s pain all too well, having gone through the same thing at a previous school, and tells Kurt to remember his courage.
Sure enough, the next time his bully slams him against his own locker, Kurt finally confronts the brutish Dave with Dave’s own insecurities. In case you haven’t seen it yet, we won’t spoil the episode any further. But needless to say, Dave is sent running.
Despite this moment of triumph for Kurt, the episode doesn’t fabricate a magical solution to Kurt’s bullying, and it’s to the show’s credit that the writers took a more (sadly) realistic direction. However, Glee did give Kurt two very important things that can be shared by all young fans who might find themselves in the same painful situation; the knowledge that he is not going through it alone and the hope that his life can and will change for the better.
A recent Entertainment Weekly article called Kurt Hummel “one of the most socially important characters on television,” but his story is no mere afterschool special. More importantly, the article also points out that Kurt “has unequivocally become the heart of the series,” which demonstrates how powerfully his story has resonated with a wider audience. Chris Colfer’s portrayal of Kurt was even nominated for an Emmy Award after just one season of the show, which also won the award for Outstanding Comedy Series at the 21st Annual GLAAD Media Awards.




about 2 years ago
I stumbled upon Glee, without really knowing what it was, some time ago. Besides the in some cases trivial story, I found Kurt. The typical gay teen and his struggle with himself and everyone around him. I was surprised how well the story developed, and yes there are some typical fel-good moments (where you can barely hold back the tears), but they keep the seriousness. It’s not easy being young and gay, but it gets better. Haven’s seen the last episode but looking forward to it.
about 2 years ago
never heard of “glee”…not even as a alone standing word, and surely not as “glee club” meaning music club. I’ve heard of the word gleeful though.
about 2 years ago
If you have an English language dictionary, open it. It’s been around for a long time. As a teen I took the glee class because I liked to sing and was not athletic. “Gleeclub” is a single word in my dictionary meaning a “choral group whose object is to sing together.” AND, I’m not gay nor were there any known gays in our group!
about 2 years ago
Funny how words and terms fall out of fashion. In high school I was a member of Boys Glee.
about 2 years ago
i just hate every single song they sing, because if soudns so manipulated and fake,….
but kurt and the importance of his story for today’s (us-american) world is really the best part of the show.
about 2 years ago
I could say the same,I absolutely abhor the digitally tuned voices but hey if it gets meaningful messages across why not.
about 2 years ago
“because [if soudns] so manipulated and fake”
You mean, like EVERY OTHER MUSICAL movie you’ve ever seen? It’s pretty much designed that way! Glee is (with its music) just a “serial” 45-minute version of a musical movie. And most MUSICALS will be that way: an instant break-out in music that’s been tuned so it sounds wonderful and (this could be the most important part) so the songs SELL WELL in their mediums (mp3s, CDs and later, DVDs of the episodes).
I agree with most of you — the social “stories” can help a lot of the “fringe outcasts” in our schools today (at least I hope). And, even though it’s (by design) a bit camp, at least it’s a good and popular GAY character which we (USA, at least) need so desperately on TV today to project to a “hungry audience.” ‹(•¿•)›
about 2 years ago
no – glee is, from a sound-tech-point of view, really particualrly bad, worse than really anything i’ve ever seen. “wonderful” is really not the adjective here.
i suspect a directorial decision behind that, because the aesthetics are strongly different from all musical tv-productions of compareable budget. everybody notices that. i guess this is a concession to younger audiences, who know people singing mostly from over-engineered cheapshit records made by artists who aren’t very good at singing. – and kind of prefer that artificial, pitch-overcorrected-plastic-sound over real people singing real notes with real emotional expression.
this is generally what i hate most about glee – they have the nicest ideas about musicmaking, but when it comes to the practicalities of actual performing, all that comes out of the protagonists’ mouths is electronic garbage. it bums me out to see characters developed as people who love to sing, and when they open their mouths, .. *argh*.
this is relly SO cheap.. like the cheapshit 3d-animations in LOST. it hurts my heart.
but that’s off topic.
about 2 years ago
OK. I thought you meant the storyline — build up character, breakout into a song & dance …. character and story …. song again ….. etc. That’s what musicals are all about.
Well, I can’t argue about any of the techical sound quality you are talking about. But I don’t think it’s as bad as you just described. But I will agree that some of the music can be way off and some of the singers (particularly a few of the highlighted ones who prefer screaming & whining to actual harmonious singing) can sound pretty tacky. But, some of them (at least how it comes across on TV) do sound pretty good (I’m aware of much of the “off stage” editing and sound dubbing) — at least to me. And it does improve the camp of the stories.
I can agree with you about “concession to younger audiences … kind of prefer that artificial, pitch-[over-corrected]-plastic-sound.” For some of them, that pretty much hits the nail on the head.
All in all, it’s still enjoyable to watch, and as another pointed out, “Sue” is a hoot to watch. I just wish a few more of the guys would be more “front & center” — they highlight too many of the girls, one of whom I think to be a real bitch and revels in her “stage time” to overpower the others. ‹(•¿•)›
about 2 years ago
This review validates your points about the musical productions, but also offers an alternative view of the episode than above.
http://www.npr.org/blogs/monkeysee/2010/11/10/131212955/why-glee-missed-the-mark-with-the-much-hyped-never-been-kissed
I don’t watch the show, so I don’t know. But the review seems to raise interesting questions.
about 2 years ago
While I agree with many of the things the critic said, he sounded more like a contrarian than someone who actually represents the “polarization” he suggests exists among viewers on this episode. There’s no denying the situation between bullies and the bullied is much more complex than what happened in the show, but I don’t think anyone’s going to get the idea to start swimming with sharks overnight. And as much as I thought the guy kissing Beast (sp) was laughable for exactly the reason the critic states, I think overall he or she was overthinking a show that is notorious for its shallowness — that being the main reason I don’t watch the show in the first place (the other reason being that I don’t like music that much). But I’m glad I watched this episode. I thought it was sweet, and I certainly hope there are hoards of gay teens out there who get a little more strength by seeing a gay boy on TV to whom they can relate and even look up to. Frankly, I think it’s sad the critic was so cynical; it was one of the first truly touching moments on television the young gay generation could cling to and already people are trying to tell them to look away?
about 2 years ago
@Rusty:
“… show that is notorious for its shallowness — that being the main reason I don’t watch the show in the first place (the other reason being that I don’t like music that much)”
If you haven’t watched 98% of this series, how do you really know you don’t like its music? They’ve had so many different styles/varieties of music — I would think that at least some of it would appeal to most everyone. If you steadfastly “hate” the wide variety of music in the series, I can’t help but wonder what type you actually listen to for enjoyment (because pretty much all the types teens listen to are in the different episodes). It seems YOU are being just a bit over-critical of the story lines and music if you haven’t seen/heard most of it — don’t you think? And, after seeing how the series was initially advertised (the early trailers), how serious would you expect this type of series would actually be — especially with song & dance entwined in all the stories? ‹(•¿•)›
about 2 years ago
“different styles/varieties of music”
yeah, theoretically. it just sounds all the same. something that irks me as a musician. i mean.. how can one know the musical styles behind what’s depicted on glee AND see what’s depicted on glee and not find it really f*ing meh?
what “glee” is great for though is its intellecutal take on performing, personal development and expression. people running around in Gaga-costumes -> that’s what i like glee for.
about 2 years ago
You misread. I just don’t like music that much.
about 2 years ago
OK, sorry. I guess you won’t be expecting an iPod for Xmas this year. ‹(•¿•)›
about 2 years ago
lol
about 2 years ago
While I can argue that Glee’s characters are often superficial and two-dimensional, I applaud the writers’ effort to include the types of kids who are outcasts in the typical high school. Glee has also sparked an interest in group singing–an art form which as been kept alive by gay men’s choruses.
about 2 years ago
I think Kurt’s in love! Apart from the breathing and quickened heartbeats you can’t see, (I know he’s fictional),
I thought I seen the actors eyes light up? So either he’s a superb actor, (which he is), or the actor as well as the character likes what he sees. I think Chris Coffer, as every bit as Kurt Hummel, likes what he see’s as well. :-)
Whiterabbit.
about 2 years ago
Yes some episodes are more like music videos it’s not a serious drama but does have some social messages. Chris colfer is one the youngest cast members, most are mid 20s, so high school is like a more recent memory for him.
I especially like his realionship with his father.
about 2 years ago
I’ve never liked Glee much (partly because I don’t like any of the music and partly because I don’t like the shallow characters), but I saw a few previews for it and decided to give it a watch. I thought it was fantastic and sweet. If all their shows were like that, I could watch it. I know a lot of people like it though, so I’m glad there are some really socially relevant parts to the show for the youth of today to latch onto.
about 2 years ago
I have yet to see Glee as I am retired on a fixed income and cannot afford cable tv. I like what I hear about the show. I’m happy to see that young gay kids today have a show like this to watch. That very thought makes me tear up as I went through so much pain as a young teen hiding in the closet during the earily 1960′s. What is really sad is that I was a good looking kid and should have had a lot of fun. I am confident that in my next life it will be better.
about 2 years ago
I’m assuming that you may not receive any local daily newspaper also. If so, then just Google: “TV listings [your zip code here]” (without the quotes). Glee is on Tuesday nights, probably either 8 or 9 PM. ‹(•¿•)›
about 2 years ago
Bruce….you can see/pirate *anything* from piratebay.org
But, you didn’t hear that from me.;-)
about 2 years ago
Since it appears you have a web connection, you can watch full episodes of Glee online. http://www.fox.com/glee/
about 2 years ago
re: #10
hey Bruce, Glee is on FOX, a broadcast network, not cable tv! it can also be seen free on fox.com (i assume you’re online – duh). and/or you can probably borrow the DVDs from your local public library!
re: Glee, liking the music is subjective, but the social issues and especially the dialogue (Sue Sylvester’s more than anyone’s, but Brittany gets some gr8 lines too) make it all worthwhile :)
about 2 years ago
I despise this show with every fiber of my being. The characters are so freakin’ annoying that I could give a crap less about any of them. I didn’t make it beyond the second episode for that reason. And I’m sorry, but the gay kid is nothing but one huge stereotype. It’s not groundbreaking in any way, shape, or form. It’s total crap.
about 2 years ago
Hey ngabear…..don’t hold anything back, OK?;-)
about 2 years ago
I feel more or less the same as you, and have only seen parts of a couple of episodes. Something attracted me to this particular episode though, so I watched it and enjoyed it quite a lot. I won’t be watching anymore, but for what it’s worth, this one episode was a gem.
about 2 years ago
I mostly watch Glee to get an idea of how Hollywood is reacting to high schoolers/selling a musical story about high school kids to, mostly, today’s high school kids. It’s got high points and low points, like any TV show. I think, to some degree, that it’s degree of acceptance is demonstrated by the number of Emee nominations it got.