Fucking wrong.

Are you a poe? No one can be this stupid, right? “Killing someone is not killing someone.” That is what you are saying.

“What makes us human is our humanity.”

And killing people is not humane. Thanks for helping my argument.

“It does not make me a monster to want justice.”

Justice is not punishment. Justice is not revenge. You do not warp justice into what you want it to mean.

“It would be my responsibility in fact.”

And then you would be arrested for murder because murder is only legal when the state does it. You would be a victim of your own hypocritical government. And then you would say “I was just getting revenge!” But the people would have no sympathy for you; you are not a state murderer, and the state is the only class of murderers they have sympathy for, even if a citizen does the exact same thing.

“When someone treats human life like dirt, they should be treated like dirt.”

Then who is going to treat you like dirt for treating the murderer like dirt? Regardless of his incredibly terrible actions, he is still a human being. Biology doesn’t give a shit about how many people you’ve killed.

If my ex-girlfriend killed someone in cold blood, I witness it, and the state won’t kill her, it wouldn’t be wrong to kill her. It would be my responsibility in fact.

When someone treats human life like dirt, they should be treated like dirt.

You’d make a good Tea Partier if you were American.

Yes. Especially the way with some of these people think. Wanting to commit murder is bad enough. Then you have people that go all out, saying things like “I WANT TO NAIL HIS EYES TO A BOARD THROUGH THE BACK OF HIS HEAD, AND FORCEFEED HIM SHIT WITH A RUSTY METAL TUBE.” And they say it with the kind of zeal and complete lack of remorse that the person they want revenge on would have used. Maybe even more, depending on how remorseful the criminal is.

It’s kind of funny; if you kill, say, your ex-girlfriend out of rage for revenge, you’re a monster, but if the state kills someone out of revenge, they’re saving society. That’s a pretty telling double standard no one wants to admit.

“Norway could keep its freedom and democracy while punishing an evil man who gave up his right to live.”

On the other hand, maybe they have their astounding freedom because they are a peaceful non-violent society and you don’t see the mass murders you see in other countries because violence is just something that doesn’t cross their mind. And this would be a step away from that. Your ideas are poisonous to this country’s freedom, not helpful.